Showing posts with label health care. Show all posts
Showing posts with label health care. Show all posts

Don't do this: 150 medical practices that all fail, especially acupuncture

This is ineffective - and cruel.
Why do people keep doing things to their bodies that don't work, and that even hurt them? This seemingly self-destructive behavior is what allows bad medicine to thrive. One problem is that people are easily fooled by self-interested con artists selling snake oil: homeopathy and acupuncture fall into this category. Another problem is that even doctors can be fooled, especially when a practice seems to make sense.

One great example of this is stenting: the use of a small, flexible tube to re-open and hold open clogged arteries. This seems like such a reasonable idea–if a pipe is clogged, unclog it and put something in there to keep it clear. And it does work, sometimes, but the evidence shows that for people with minor blockage, it usually does more harm than good. A new article in The Atlantic, "When Evidence Says No, but Doctors Say Yes", explains that in a recent 5-year period in the U.S., "about half of all stent placements in stable patients were either definitely or possibly inappropriate," as shown in a new study. The authors also point out that stenting remains the go-to procedure for any patient with clogged arteries, even among physicians who have read the studies. The problem here is that stenting just seems so darned logical.

At least stents work some of the time. What about procedures and medications that don't work at all, and that sometimes cause harm? Five years ago, a team of scientists in Australia conducted a massive review of evidence for thousands of medical practices, and found 156 that either don't work or actually cause harm. Their list of ineffective and harmful procedures should be required reading for anyone who is considering a medical procedure.

I can't go through all 156 bad practices, but one group of procedures stands out as particularly ridiculous (by which I mean the original sense of the word, "deserving of ridicule"). These are the various uses of acupuncture, all of them ineffective, none of them with even the slightest plausibility, but all of them promoted by quacks acupuncturists. Here they are–and remember, each of these has been tested scientifically and shown to be either useless or, even worse, harmful:

  1. Acupuncture for women in labor. From the study: "In the absence of sufficient evidence that proves either effectiveness or harm, acupuncture as a method of induction is not recommended."
  2. Acupuncture for uterine fibroids. "There is no reliable proof of effectiveness of acupuncture for uterine fibroids." (Aside: if a woman has fibroids, multiple options are available, many quite effective. The claim that acupuncture might treat them is patently ridiculous.)
  3. Acupuncture for irritable bowel syndrome. Studies have found "no significant effect of acupuncture on IBS global symptoms, pain, and quality of life compared with placebo." 
  4. Acupuncture for otitis media with effusion (fluid in the middle ear). This condition is common in children, and acupuncturists are only too happy to plunge their needles into unsuspecting kids. The study found no evidence that this works, and concluded that "acupuncture should not be used for the management of patients with OME."
  5. Acupuncture for lower urinary tract symptoms in men. This too doesn't work. I wonder where they stick the needles?
  6. Acupuncture to treat hyperbilirubinaemia. This condition, commonly known as jaundice, is often seen in very young infants. The suggest that we treating babies with acupuncture is, frankly, primitive and terribly cruel. The study concluded starkly that "there is no evidence to support the use of acupuncture to treat hyperbilirubinaemia–NICE recommends that this treatment not be used in this population." (NICE is the Australian National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.)
  7. Laser acupuncture for carpal tunnel syndrome. Multiple studies found that acupuncture doesn't work for this either. One study concluded that "more rigorous studies are needed." Why waste more time on this hopeless pursuit?
  8. Acupuncture for depression. Lots of studies, most with a "high risk of bias," and all of them finding that acupuncture doesn't work for depression. This is depressing.
  9. Acupuncture for osteoarthritis. Not surprising, acupuncture for arthritis is no better than placebo.
  10. Acupuncture for Bell's palsy. Eight trials, none of them showing any reliable benefits. Subject patients to more of these trials would be cruel and unethical.

So there you have it: 10 out of the 156 bad medical practices involved acupuncture. If you want to see the rest of the list, check out the full study. As for acupuncture, this is by no means a complete list of the claims that acupuncturists make. Indeed, just last week a new study claimed that acupuncture helps treat migraines, prompting a rebuttal from UC San Francisco's Amy Gelfand, in the same journal, saying no, it doesn't. (Dr. Gelfand explained a lot more than that, but I'm summarizing.) The pro-acupuncture study was done in China, where virtually all acupuncture studies report positive results, and the lead author works at the Acupuncture and Tuina School, Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine.

We should all thank Drs. Elshaug, Watt, Mundy, and Willis for their tireless effort in reviewing thousands of studies, so that the rest of us don't have to. Acupuncture studies will keep appearing, but there's no reason to believe anything new will emerge. It's time for people to stop fooling themselves about this particular brand of pre-scientific pseudoscience.




British Health Minister believes in magic water


Well, this is one way to save money on health care.  The new British Minister of Health, Jeremy Hunt, is a firm believer in homeopathy, which treats disease using magic water solutions that contain - well, only water.

Just a few days ago, British prime minister David Cameron shuffled his cabinet, moving Hunt from Minister of Culture to his new position in charge of health.  Within hours, Tom Chivers, a science editor at the Telegraph, reported on Hunt's belief in homeopathy:
"The man put in charge of the nation's health policy is on record as supporting spending public money on magic water to cure disease." 
He went on to add:
"This is not unlike putting someone who thinks the Second World War began in 1986 in charge of the Department of Education."
Not surprisingly, Chivers' blog post was flooded with hundreds of comments, many of them from upset defenders of homeopathy.  Most of their arguments boiled down to "I think it works for me, so there."

Homeopathy is one of the most absurd, wildly implausible forms of quack medicine. I've written about it many times (for example, about the bogus flu pills sold as oscillococcinum,
about NCCAM's embarrassing funding of studies of homeopathy, and about how homeopaths offer strychnine to cure children's colds), so I'll try not to repeat myself.  Homeopathy is founded on two basic notinos, both of them dead wrong:

  1. Infinitely diluted substances are more potent than substances at higher concentrations, and
  2. "Like cures like," meaning that if a substance causes a symptom, you can use that substance to cure the symptom.  

Thus caffeine can be used to help you sleep, and poison ivy can cure itching.  No, I'm not making this up; homeopaths really believe this stuff.

Homeopathy is simply magical thinking.  There has never been a shred of scientific evidence to support it, and the British Medical Association declared in 2010 that homeopathy is witchcraft.  After pressure from science bloggers, NIH's NCCAM has corrected its website to state that
"it is not possible to explain in scientific terms how a remedy containing little or no active ingredient can have any effect."
But homeopaths make a lot of money selling homeopathic potions, and through clever marketing they keep themselves in business.  Now they have a new ally, the UK Minister of Health. Andy Coghlan, writing in The New Scientist, called him "the new minister for magic."  Brilliant!  As Coghlan pointed out, magic is much cheaper than real medicine:
"Think of the savings if all those expensive proven treatments and drugs are phased out, and patients are offered cheap little vials of water instead."
We're desperately looking for ways to control health care costs here in the U.S. as well.  The UK Minister of Magic may have a solution for us.  I wonder, though, if it works for muggles?