Showing posts with label gingko biloba. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gingko biloba. Show all posts

Does ginkgo biloba enhance memory? I forgot.

I recently saw an ad that claimed ginkgo biloba can treat the signs of dementia. A quick search on Amazon.com yielded hundreds of products, many claiming that gingko is a "brain sharpener" or that it "supports focus, memory, brain function and mental performance," or other similar claims.

Ginkgo biloba is a supplement made from the leaves of the gingko biloba tree, which is native to China. The supplements industry claims that gingko has been used for thousands of years to improve memory and stave off dementia. While that may be true (though I doubt it), the argument that a medical treatment was used by pre-scientific cultures is not exactly compelling. After all, people died very young in ancient times, and medical knowledge was little more than superstition, for the most part. I don't know about you, but when I'm looking for medicine, I want the latest stuff.

"But wait!" say ginkgo biloba's advocates: maybe those ancient folk doctors were onto something. Maybe so–and it didn't take me long to find multiple studies testing what those ancients supposedly believed about gingko biloba:

  1. Here's a review from 2009 that looked at gingko biloba for dementia and milder cognitive impairment. It reported that "the evidence that Ginkgo biloba has clinically significant benefit for people with dementia or cognitive impairment is inconsistent and unreliable." Not exactly a ringing endorsement.
  2. Here's another study, from 2012, looking at the effect of gingko biloba on memory in healthy individuals. Is it a "brain sharpener"? Well, no. This study found that gingko "had no ascertainable positive effects on a range of targeted cognitive functions in healthy individuals." In other words, a total dud.
  3. And here's an even more recent study, from 2015. The result: "no convincing evidence ... that demonstrated Ginkgo biloba in late-life can prevent the development of dementia. Using it for this indication is not suggested."

Given that the science says this doesn't work, you might wonder how it is that hundreds of gingko biloba products are still on the market, all of them with claims about memory. Simple: it's a dietary supplement, not a drug, which means that it is essentially unregulated (in the U.S.). The FDA won't step in unless the marketing claims get so outrageous that they cross the line into medicine–and even then, the FDA rarely does more than send a sternly worded letter.

As I've written before, supplement marketing is like the wild west. You generally can't trust anything you read from the manufacturers, except perhaps the ingredients list. And even the ingredients are sometimes inaccurate and contaminated.

(By the way, I find it especially amusing when a pill that has no effect is advertised as "double strength," as Walgreens does for one of their gingko products, here.)

So be skeptical about the marketing claims for gingko biloba. Even NCCIH, the NIH institute whose mission is to promote "alternative" medicine, is remarkably clear about this, stating that:

  • "There’s no conclusive evidence that ginkgo is helpful for any health condition.
  • Ginkgo doesn’t help prevent or slow dementia or cognitive decline.
  • There’s no strong evidence that ginkgo helps with memory enhancement in healthy people, blood pressure, intermittent claudication, tinnitus, age-related macular degeneration, the risk of having a heart attack or stroke, or with other conditions."

I must say, I'm feeling a bit better about NCCIH these days. They got this one right. The bottom line: don't waste your money on gingko biloba.

A really bad week for the supplements industry

If the ingredients in your pills don’t really work, does it matter if they’re correct?

Well, yes. Even if that echinacea pill doesn’t cure the common cold, if a supplement manufacturer sells you an echinacea pill, they have to put echinacea in it. 

Supplement makers can and do make all kinds of claims about the health benefits of the stuff they’re selling you. They claim that supplements can "boost your immune system," relieve aches and pains, improve memory, and promote "wellness," whatever the heck that means. Most this is nonsense, but thanks to the manufacturers’ special friend in the U.S. Senate, Senator Orrin Hatch, the federal government has almost no power to regulate these claims. Over the years, the supplement companies have been very generous to Senator Hatch, and he has returned the favor by defending them (though of course he denies any quid pro quo).

Even supplement makers have limits: they can’t sell you ground-up house plants, or rice powder, claiming that it’s St. Johns Wort. But as New York attorney general Eric Schneiderman revealed last week, that’s exactly what some of them have been doing. Amazingly, 79% of the supplements tested did not contain the primary ingredient listed on the label. Many of them contained other plant material, including plants that might cause an allergic reaction in unsuspecting customers.

You see, as cheap as most supplements are (compared to real medicine, that is), rice powder is even cheaper.

Attorney General Schneiderman sent letters to four of the largest retailers of supplements in the country: Walmart, Walgreens, GNC, and Target, demanding them to immediately stop selling supplements that were falsely labelled, including echinacea, ginseng, St. John’s Wort, gingko biloba, and others.

What did Schneiderman's office do? Well, they conducted a scientific study, using DNA sequencing to test the ingredients in six types of herbal supplements, looking at different brands from multiple stores. They tested each sample 5 times to ensure accuracy. They collected 78 different samples and ran 390 tests in all.

Here's what they found:
  • GNC "Herbal Plus" supplements: gingko biloba, St. John's wort, ginseng, garlic, echinacea, and saw palmetto were tested. Garlic was the only one that consistently contained what the label indicated. One out of four bottles of saw palmetto tested positive, and none of the other four supplements contained the labeled herb. Overall, 22% of the DNA tests identified the labeled ingredient. Contaminants included rice, alfalfa, and houseplant DNA.
  • Target's "Up & Up" supplements: gingko biloba, St. John's wort, Valerian root, garlic, echinacea, and saw palmetto were tested. Three supplements–garlic, saw palmetto, and echinacea–contained what they were supposed to. The other three had no DNA at all from the labeled ingredient. 
  • Walgreens "Finest Nutrition" supplements: gingko biloba, St. John's wort, ginseng, garlic, echinacea, and saw palmetto were tested. Only one of these, saw palmetto, consistently contained its labeled ingredient. One sample of garlic actually contained garlic, and none of the other samples contained any DNA from the labeled ingredient. Overally, 18% of the DNA tests found the expected ingredients. Contaminants included rice, wheat, daisy, and houseplant DNA.
  • Walmart's "Spring Valley" supplements: gingko biloba, St. John's wort, ginseng, garlic, echinacea, saw palmetto were tested. Walmart had the worst results: of 90 DNA tests on 18 bottles, only 4% found any DNA from the labeled ingredient. Only one bottle of garlic and one bottle of saw palmetto contained what they were supposed to. Contaminants included pine, grass, citrus, and cassava.
This is pretty stunning, and it's only a sample; see the AG's letters to each retailer for more details. According to the New York Times, the retailers agreed to pull the supplements off their shelves (in New York, at least) after receiving the AG's letter.

Just a couple of years ago, Senator Orrin Hatch successfully fought off an amendment that would have required supplement makers to register their products with the FDA and provide details about their ingredients. As the NY Times also reported, Hatch has received hundreds of thousands of dollars from the supplements industry over the years.

Of course, even if these bottles did contain what they were supposed to, their claims to improve memory, boost your immune system, and fight off colds are entirely unproven. Thanks to a 1994 law championed by Senator Hatch, the FDA cannot require supplement makers to prove that any of their products work, as long as they avoid specific claims to cure a specific disease. 

But if they say they're selling you gingko biloba or St. John's wort, they're supposed to put that in the pills. Instead, it seems they are selling ground-up rice and house plants.

One supplement did actually contain what it’s supposed to: garlic pills. Garlic has been investigated for its effect on cholesterol levels, where it seems to have at most a very small benefit. Garlic lovers would argue that you're losing the real benefit if you take it in pills rather than simply eating it.

And garlic does have one unique benefit: it is 100% effective at warding off vampires.