Showing posts with label epidemics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label epidemics. Show all posts

Anti-vaxxers are to blame for a new epidemic of measles in the U.S.

Measles is now spreading outward from Disneyland in California, in the worst outbreak in years. The epidemic is fueled by growing enclaves of unvaccinated people. 

The CDC reports that in just the past month, 84 people from 14 states contracted measles, a number that is certainly an under-estimate, because the CDC doesn’t record every case. California alone has 59 confirmed cases, most of them linked to an initial exposure in Disneyland. A majority of people who have gotten sick were not vaccinated.

For years, scientists (including me) have warned that the anti-vaccination movement was going to cause epidemics of disease. Two years ago I wrote that the anti-vaccine movement had caused the worst whooping cough epidemic in 70 years. And now it’s happening with measles.

Finally, though, the public seems to be pushing back. Parents are starting to wake up to the danger that the anti-vax movement represents to their children and themselves. 

What's sad about this – tragic, really – is that we eliminated measles from the U.S. in the year 2000, thanks to the measles vaccine. As this CDC graph shows, we've had fewer than 100 cases every year since. 

But we had 644 cases in 27 states in 2014, the most in 20 years. And 2015 is already on track to be worse. Measles may become endemic in the U.S, circulating continually, thanks to the increasing numbers of unvaccinated people. Until now, each outbreak was caused by someone traveling from abroad and bringing measles to us. The anti-vaccine movement has turned this public health victory into defeat.

Anti-vaxxers have been relentless in the efforts to spread misinformation. Despite overwhelming scientific evidence that vaccines are beneficial, they endlessly repeat a variety false claims, such as

Now, finally, some parents are pushing back. Parents and schools in California, where the epidemic began, are concerned that their children will be exposed to measles from unvaccinated children in schools. And the schools are starting to do something they should have done long ago: send the unvaccinated kids home.

The problem arises from California’s vaccine exemption policy: although public schools require kids to be vaccinated, parents can exempt their kids simply by saying they have a personal objection to vaccination. It’s not just California: only two states, Mississippi and West Virginia, don’t allow parents to claim a philosophical or religious exemption to vaccines  And Colorado has the worst rate of vaccination, at just 82%, primarily due to parents claiming a “philosophical” exemption.

These parents are the anti-vaxxers. Thanks to them, we now have large pockets of unvaccinated children through whom epidemics can spread further an faster than we’ve seen in decades. The CDC reports that in 2014, 79% of measles cases in the U.S. involving unvaccinated people were the result of personal belief exemptions.

Anti-vaxxers don't recognize the threat their behavior poses to others, especially to children whose immune systems aren’t functioning properly. CNN reported this week on the case of Rhett Krawitt, a 6-year-old California boy who has gone through 4 years of chemotherapy for childhood leukemia. His leukemia is in remission and he’s back in school, but the treatment wiped out his immunity, and he’s still not ready to get vaccinated. If Rhett gets measles, he might not survive. His father Carl wrote to school district officials to ask them to ban unvaccinated children from school.

Krawitt expects the schools to deny his request.

Meanwhile, the parents who refuse to vaccinate their kids aren’t budging. The New York Times reported on one mother, Crystal McDonald, who refused to vaccinate any of her four children, after “researching the issue” by reading anti-vaccine websites. When their high school sent her daughter home for two weeks, the daughter asked if she could get the measles shot so she could return. As quoted in the Times, McDonald told her daughter “I said ‘No, absolutely not.’ I said I’d rather you miss an entire semester than you get the shot.’”

Where does this breathtaking science denialism come from? It’s been building for years, as I and many others have written. The wave began with a 1998 paper published in The Lancet by Andrew Wakefield, claiming that the MMR vaccine was linked to autism. Wakefield’s work was later shown to be fraudulent, and his claims about the vaccine "dishonest and irresponsible." After lengthy investigations, the paper was retracted and Wakefield lost his medical license. Despite this very public repudiation, Wakefield has stuck to his claims, though, and has spent much of the past 15 years speaking (or perhaps “preaching” would be a better term) to anti-vaccine groups, to whom he is a kind of folk hero.

It’s not just Wakefield, though. Anti-vaccine messages have been broadcast aggressively by the group Generation Rescue, led by former Playboy playmate and MTV host Jenny McCarthy, and by Age of Autism, a group dedicated to the proposition that vaccines cause autism. (Age of Autism is doing it again right now.) And just last summer, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. published a new book further promoting the long-discredited claim that thimerosal causes autism. 

Most of the anti-vax crowd have no scientific training or expertise, which might explain (but doesn't excuse) their complete ignorance of the science. Over the past 15 years, dozens of studies involving hundreds of thousands of people have shown convincingly that neither vaccines nor any of the ingredients in them are linked to autism. Vaccines are not only safe, but they are perhaps the greatest public health success in the history of civilization.

Measles, though, is dangerous. The CDC’s Anne Schuchat had a message for parents this week:
“I want to make sure that parents who think that measles is gone and haven't made sure that they or their children are vaccinated are aware that measles is still around and it can be serious. And that MMR vaccine is safe and effective and highly recommended.”
Make no mistake, measles is a very dangerous infection. In the current outbreak, 25% of victims have ended up in the hospital. And it is extremely infectious: the CDC’s Schuchat explained that 
“You can catch it [measles] just by being in the same room as a person with measles even if that person left the room because the virus can hang around for a couple of hours.”

Perhaps the Disneyland epidemic, which has now spread to 14 states, will finally convince parents, schools, and state legislatures that they need to insist that children get vaccinated before going to school. Perhaps it will also convince parents to stop listening to nonsense, and choose wisely by getting their children vaccinated against measles. We won this battle before, and we can win it again.

Why Google Flu is a failure: the hubris of big data

It seemed like such a good idea at the time.

People with the flu (the influenza virus, that is) will probably go online to find out how to treat it, or to search for other information about the flu. So Google decided to track such behavior, hoping it might be able to predict flu outbreaks even faster than traditional health authorities such as the Centers for Disease Control (CDC).

Instead, as the authors of a new article in Science explain, we got "big data hubris."  David Lazer and colleagues explain that:
“Big data hubris” is the often implicit assumption that big data are a substitute for, rather than a supplement to, traditional data collection and analysis.
The folks at Google figured that, with all their massive data, they could outsmart anyone.

The problem is that most people don't know what "the flu" is, and relying on Google searches by people who may be utterly ignorant about the flu does not produce useful information. Or to put it another way, a huge collection of misinformation cannot produce a small gem of true information. Like it or not, a big pile of dreck can only produce more dreck. GIGO, as they say.

Google's scientist first announced Google Flu in a Nature article in 2009. With what now seems to be a textbook definition of hubris, they wrote:
"...we can accurately estimate the current level of weekly influenza activity in each region of the United States, with a reporting lag of about one day."
They obtained this remarkable accuracy entirely from analyzing Google searches. Impressive - if true.

Ironically, just a few months after announcing Google Flu, the world was hit with the 2009 swine flu pandemic, caused by a novel strain of H1N1 influenza. Google Flu missed it.

The failures have continued. As Lazer et al. show in their Science study, Google Flu was wrong for 100 out of 108 weeks since August 2011.

One problem is that Google's scientists have never revealed what search terms they actually use to track the flu. A paper they published in 2011 declares that Google Flu does a great job. The official Google blog last October makes it appear that they do an almost perfect job predicting the flu for previous years.

Haven't these guys been paying attention? It's easy to predict the past. Does anyone remember the University of Colorado professors who had a model that correctly predicted every election since 1980? In August 2012, they confidently announced that their model showed Mitt Romney winning in a landslide. Hmm.

Flu cases this year, which are dominated by H1N1.
A bigger problem with Google Flu, though, is that most people who think they have "the flu" do not. The vast majority of doctors' office visits for flu-like symptoms turn out to be other viruses. CDC tracks these visits under "influenza-like illness" because so many turn out to be something else. To illustrate, the CDC reports that in the most recent week for which data is available, only 8.8% of specimens tested positive for influenza.

When 80-90% of people visiting the doctor for "flu" don't really have it, you can hardly expect their internet searches to be a reliable source of information.

Google Flu is still there, and you can still look at its predictions, even though we know they are wrong. I recommend the CDC website instead, which is based on actual data about the influenza virus collected from actual patients. Big data can be great, but not when it's bad data.

Anti-vaccination propagandists help create the worst whooping cough epidemic in 70 years


The great northwest of the U.S. is known for its natural beauty.  It's also a high-tech region with a highly educated public - not exactly the kind of place one would expect to fall for the anti-science rhetoric of the anti-vaccine movement.

But it has.  The anti-vaxxers have convinced a frighteningly high number of parents in Washington State to withhold vaccines from their children.  A story in The Seattle Times last year reported that 
"Washington [state] parents are choosing not to vaccinate their kindergartners at a rate higher than anywhere else in the country."  
This despite the fact that the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (formed by the founder of Microsoft, which is headquartered in Seattle) is one of the world's leading sponsors of vaccine research.  

When the vaccination rates drop, everyone becomes more vulnerable to infectious diseases.  When more than 90% of the population is vaccinated, we have "herd immunity" - this means the disease can't spread because there aren't enough susceptible people in the community.  So the high rate of vaccine refusal in Washington makes it easier for whooping cough (and other diseases) to spread.

The media has been complicit in spreading some of the anti-vaccine misinformation.  Sometimes it comes straight from the media itself, such as the credulous, anti-science, anti-vax CBS reporter Sharyl Attkisson. Other times it comes from talk shows, magazines, or even airline advertisements that provide a platform for anti-vax celebrity doctors such as Jay Gordon (who gained fame as Jenny McCarthy's son's doctor) and "Dr. Bob" Sears, who has published his own "alternative" vaccine schedule in a book filled with anti-vaccine nonsense.  These characters continue to claim, at every chance they get, that vaccines cause autism (as Gordon has said, repeatedly), or that they cause other harms, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary.  They use their medical degrees and their faux concern "for the children" to frighten parents into keeping their kids unvaccinated.

And now we learn that the U.S. is in the midst of the worst whooping cough epidemic in 70 years.  One of the most hard-hit states is Washington, which the CDC just announced (on 20 July) has suffered 2,520 cases so far this year, a 1300% increase over last year.  This is the highest number of cases reported in Washington since 1942.  This plot of the number of cases this year compared to last year shows the dramatic rise in infections:
The figure above shows the number of confirmed and probable pertussis cases reported, by week of onset in Washington, during January 1, 2011-June 16, 2012.  Source: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Making things worse, it seems, is an increase in cases among children aged 13-14.  Children get a booster shot at age 11-12, but the new outbreak indicates that the effectiveness of the booster may not last very long.  The dramatic increase in whooping cough this year also suggests that the bacterium that causes it, Bordetella pertussis, is mutating to make the vaccine less effective.  Nevertheless, the CDC emphasizes: 
"Vaccination continues to be the single most effective strategy to reduce morbidity and mortality caused by pertussis. Vaccination of pregnant women and contacts of infants is recommended to protect infants too young to be vaccinated."
This good advice is seriously undermined when misinformed doctors such as "Dr. Bob" Sears directly advise pregnant women not to get the whooping cough vaccine, as he did in the Huffington Post. (Hint: it's a good rule to be very skeptical of celebrity doctors who go by their first name.)

I should also point out that whooping cough is a national problem, not just Washington State's.  The U.S. has had over 17,000 cases this year, putting it on track for the worst year since 1959.  The highest rate of infection in the nation is in Wisconsin (which has also been hit hard by anti-vaccine effects), followed by Washington and Montana. 10 deaths have been reported, mostly in infants who were too young to be vaccinated.  For all this, we can thank the anti-vaccination movement.

"Recontrolling pertussis": a phrase we shouldn't have to hear

The word is going out that a lot of people need to get a pertussis booster shot Pertussis, more commonly known as whooping cough, is a bacterial infection that is very dangerous and sometimes fatal in young infants, whose immune systems are too immature to protect them. The only way to protect the very young is to make sure those around them -- parents, siblings, other relatives, and day care providers -- are vaccinated. Many adults were vaccinated as children, but the vaccine's protection wanes after about ten years, so they still need a booster shot if they are caring for children.


What's new here? First, there's a new report from an expert advisory panel to the Centers for Disease Control. The CDC panel is urging doctors to vaccinate everyone who might be in contact with young children, even if they can't remember when or if they had the pertussis vaccine. A report in the Journal of the American Medical Association this past week quotes pertussis expert Michael Brady, M.D., who chairs the American Academy of Pediatrics committee on infectious diseases, who says the new recommendations are needed as part of our efforts at "recontrolling pertussis."


What does Dr. Brady mean when he says "recontrolling"? Well, whooping cough is not under control right now. In California, a serious epidemic continues. (See my previous post about it here.) The CDC reports over 7,800 cases of pertussis throughout California, including the deaths of 10 infants. These infants were too young to be vaccinated, and their deaths are a tragedy that could have been prevented. The last time we saw this many cases of whooping cough in California was 63 years ago, in 1947.


Meanwhile, Michigan continues to have its own pertussis outbreak, with 1,092 cases this year, and 902 cases last year. And the pertussis epidemic has spread to Ohio, where two counties collectively report 910 cases this year, the largest number in 25 years.


In infants and very young children, pertussis causes violent, spasmodic coughing that repeats over and over. The cough is so strong that babies cannot breath properly, and after multiple coughs they will breathe in sharply with a classic "whooping" sound, which gives the disease its name. Pertussis is far more dangerous in infants than in adults: from 2000-2004, 92% of the pertussis deaths in the U.S. were in children less than one year old.


Whooping cough used to be under control. The number of nationwide cases was dropping for years, and although the disease didn't disappear, we were getting to the point where most people didn't know anyone who'd had it. The question is, why did we lose control? Is a new strain of pertussis to blame? Or is it our own behavior?


Unfortunately, the answer seems to be that these outbreaks are spreading as a result of falling vaccine rates, for which we can thank the anti-vaccine movement, which has been very effective at getting their message out through mainsteam media, including the Larry King show, Oprah, and The Huffington Post. One of the main groups in this movement is the mis-named National Vaccine Information Center, which really should be called the Vaccine Misinformation Center. Their pertussis web page contains a section titled "Can pertussis vaccine cause brain damage and death?" The mere act of asking this question is part of their anti-vaccine strategy. And rather than answering "no," the website goes on for several paragraphs, selectively quoting from studies that looked at vaccine risks - which are very small, but not zero - while ignoring the much greater risks of the disease itself. NVIC's website concludes by claiming (without citation) that

"Most pediatric neurologists acknowledge that vaccination, including use of vaccines for smallpox, rabies, influenza, mumps, measles, tetanus, polio and pertussis, can and does occasionally cause neurological complications that can lead to permanent brain dysfunction."

Scare tactics indeed. Not only is NVIC trying to scare parents away from the pertussis vaccine, but they take the opportunity to warn against many other vaccines. NVIC claims on its website that it "does not promote the use of vaccines and does not advise against the use of vaccines," but that, to put it bluntly, is a lie. Their primary mission is anti-vaccine advocacy, as illustrated by their current advertising campaign that claims we are "over-vaccinating" children and injecting them with harmful toxins.


So we can thank NVIC and other anti-vaccine groups, such as Generation Rescue (which claims, among many other mistaken notions, that the pertussis vaccine causes autism), for the re-emergence of whooping cough.


In contrast, here's what the CDC says about the pertussis vaccine:

"Results from clinical trials showed that these vaccines are very safe for infants and children....The most common adverse events reported have been tenderness and redness where the shot was given, headache, diarrhea, and fussiness."
Unlike NVIC, the CDC gives details and citations to the scientific literature. The CDC also maintains a separate page listing all possible side effects from a long list of vaccines.

The current vaccine against whooping cough is called DTaP or TDaP (short for " tetanus toxoid, reduced diphtheria toxoid and acellular pertussis", and the evidence shows that it is very safe. The vaccine does not contain any whole cell, not even killed bacteria, meaning that it is impossible for the vaccine to cause even a mild case of any of the diseases that it protects against.


The CDC advisory on the pertussis vaccine is not part of a conspiracy to "over-vaccinate" the public, or to pad the profits of Big Pharma. (By the way, to pre-empt some of the commenters: I am not paid a single penny by any pharmaceutical company, nor am I paid by Forbes.) The advisory is a necessary step to "recontrol" whooping cough, a disease that we should not have let back into our communities. I fear that if we keep listening to the anti-vaccine activists, pertussis will be just the first in a series of diseases that will return to plague us, causing needless suffering and anguish.